The Possibly Forgotten Optional `else` in Python’s `try` Statement

This post discusses the else clause in Python’s try statement. Although this particular use of else may not be as forgotten and controversial as its use in Python loops, a gentle reminder of how it works and when it’s useful may still be beneficial. Please note that this post only focuses on the else clause of the try statement and does not intend to cover the entire try statement. For a pretty good initial explanation of how the entire try statement works, refer to the official Python documentation on this topic.

A “normal” stripped down try statement seen regularly looks something like this:

    # some code that might raise exception
    # code to handle exception
    # code to run regardless of exception 

This is “normal” in the sense that to anyone coming from most other programming languages can understand/guess what it means:

The big difference between exception handling in Python and other languages is that in Python using exceptions for flow control is common and normal. In fact, in many cases, you must use exceptions for control-flow. This is where the else clause comes in.

The optional else clause, which has to be before the finally clause (if there is one), is executed if and when control flows off the end of the try clause. Currently, control “flows off the end” except in the case of an exception or the execution of a return, continue, or break statement. So, for example:

>>> try:
...    print("Try: I'll try not to raise an exception.")
... except:
...    print("Except: You hopefully won't see me.")
... else:
...    print("Else: No exceptions was raised.")
... finally:
...    print("Finally: I'm going to run anyway.")
Try: I'll try not to raise an exception.
Else: No exceptions was raised.
Finally: I'm going to run anyway.

 But, why!?

As mentioned earlier, it is very common to use Python’s try statement as to control the flow of our program. So, the else clause is a very neat way of executing some code if an exception isn’t raised.
For instance, one way to check if a file exists is:

    f = open('some-file.txt')
except IOError:
    print("File doesn't exist :-(")
    print("File exists!")

If some-file.txt exists and opens successfully, then an exception will not be raised and the else clause will be executed (File exists! will be printed). Otherwise, the else clause will not be executed (File doesn't exist :-( will be printed).

Also, without the else clause, the only option to run additional code before finalization (which is rare) would be the clumsy practice of adding the code to the try clause. This is clumsy because it risks raising exceptions in code that wasn’t intended to be protected by the try statement.

In general, there is probably not a case where you have no choice but to use the else clause in a try statement. But, besides allowing you to control the flow of your program without much hassle, it will often make the code more elegant, readable and Pythonic as well.

Discussion on hackernews and reddit.


Now read this

The Forgotten Optional `else` in Python Loops

This post discusses Python’s for...else and while...else syntax, one of the most rarely used and misunderstood syntactic features in Python. Both for and while loops in Python also take an optional else suite (like the if statement and... Continue →